Pat McGrath Labs

Mothership V: Bronze Seduction Palette, $125

The colors in this palette are “stunning,” “incredible,” and “unreal” according to our judges. The 10 shades range from a classic matte brown to a galactic green-gold-pink shimmer, with the ideal metallic bronze and wild shiny vermillion in there, too. “A little goes a long way with these shadows,” Nina Park said of the creamy powders. Jane Larkworthy likes using a wet brush to use the matte shades as liners.

Shop Now

“I love the variety of finishes here. With its serious weight and breathtaking packaging, this one’s a museum piece.” —Jane Larkworthy

“Ten stunning shades. Blendable mattes. Must-have shimmer shades. This palette is everything I ever wanted!” —Marianna Hewitt

“Incredible selection of colors for anyone new or seasoned to eyeshadows.” —Daniel Martin

Most Eye-Catching


Scattered Light Glitter Shadow, $29

Any time you blink when you wear these shadows, it's like a little light flashing from your eyes. In fact, these five metallics are so brilliant, Marianna Hewitt told us she was “SHOOK.” And everyone commented on how easy they are to use, especially with your finger. “No-brainer eyeshadow at its best,” said Kahlana Barfield Brown.

Shop Now

Best Steal


Curator Wet to Dry Eye Palette, $14

With pretty colors and subtle-but-noticeable finishes, Undone is one of Coveteur’s favorite new brands of the year. This 10-shade eyeshadow palette, which comes in three different colorways, gives super sheer shimmery washes of color when used dry, and becomes more fun and high impact when you use them with a wet brush.

Shop Now

Wake up to Louboutins with our newsletter.
Sign up Already! 

It's the internet equivalent of a friendship bracelet.

You did it! Thanks for joining our newsletter list.

Looks like you have already subscribed.

Error, please enter a valid email address