As fashion and beauty editors-in-residence, we spend most of our days trying to track down that next best thing—the newest eyeliner flick, pant flair, contouring blend (still lost on that one, tbh)—but there’s something to say about the staples: that perfect bag, jean, boot, bottle of wine…the things that keep you grounded, you know? So when it comes to beauty, we have our go-tos on auto replenishment, as it seems most cosmetic-wearers do. So, in a search to find our next makeup staple, we asked the big-gun beauty retailers what their customers ordered most. From cult classics to green beauty, here’s what the people wanted (and bought).