Lilli Kay is a New York girl. You can tell by the way she opens her front door and ushers you inside her Brooklyn apartment, politely requesting that you take your shoes off as you come in, the way so many natives do. Only, she didn’t grow up here. Kay was raised in Venice, California, in Dogtown “back when it was still freaky,” she tells me. Despite growing up in close proximity to Hollywood, that didn’t stop Kay from moving to New York to pursue a career in acting—a decision that came from being drawn to the creativity and authenticity that this city runs on. Almost a decade into her city residence, her career is growing as much as her love for the city.
Most recently, Kay just finished filming in Poland for an untitled project with Jeremiah Zagar— who, she tells me, is one of her favorite collaborators she’s ever worked with—and stars in the sports comedy series Stick, where she plays a bartender-turned golf caddy, Christina "Zero" Duffy, which is on its second season. Something about Zero is that they are uncompromising in their values, a trait that trickles into Kay’s obvious self-assuredness when we interface.
On the day of our shoot in Prospect Park, we meet in her apartment. Kay is in an oversized T-shirt and basketball shorts, ready to get into a new character. She is easygoing and enthusiastic, a mix of LA-ease and New Yorker grit that makes her both discerning and laid-back. She's currently moving apartments—something that New Yorkers are always doing every few years, and Kay is excited for a new space and chapter. She tells us this as she apologizes for her almost pristine space, which is charmingly adorned with knick-knacks that speak to Kay’s personal style: a half-finished painting (not by her) in the kitchen of a man who resembles Anthony Hopkins, a deep and cozy chocolate colored couch that blends in with her tendrils of curly hair, and piles of books pushed into the corner.
As for where she’s at in her life, being a young actor can come with its challenges. Long days on set, being away from loved ones, maintaining community when you’re building your career—all of these are things that Kay naturally struggles with, but the trade off of gratitude to be doing what she loves is worth it when you have good people around you. “It's so cool to have people who motivate you and inspire and challenge you,” she says. “I really feel that I have that right now.”
Ahead, we catch up about growing up in a creative environment, how rewarding it is to hone her craft, and how New York City has shaped her as an actor.
Dior jacket, jeans, and shoes.Tell us about your Stick character, Zero.
“Zero is so wonderful and such a special character to me. The thing I was the most excited about with this new season is that we get to see a more grown-up side of her. She's existing in the real world in a way that we didn't get to see in the first season, where we're on this summer camp RV adventure, and we get to see who this person is when met with new challenges and grown-up challenges again.
Do you resonate with her as a person?
“Yeah. She is really unapologetically herself, and really passionate. She's a lot of things that I hope to be, that I admire.”
We talked about her style on set a little bit—how does the difference in your style help you drop into the process of becoming Zero?
“Something that we share is that we both have pretty distinct and clear senses of personal style, but it's a really helpful element to have a very different visual language or visual aesthetic to drop into with a character. I’ve been leaning more femme than I have in the past and exploring what that looks and feels like for me. My style mostly just ends up being an externalization of my inner life at any given moment. I dress for where I’m at, and who I need to be on that day. Often less premeditated than I’d like it to be. I’m excited to see what shape it takes next. And then she has such a specific and clear articulation of her personal style that it really does immediately change things when you put the clothes on. So just having that as a tool is really helpful. That evolves a lot this season, which was very interesting to explore and exciting as someone who really loves clothing as an expression.”
Stella McCartney top, skirt, and shoes.
Stella McCartney top, skirt, and shoes.Did you grow up able to express your creativity?
“I grew up surrounded by creative people. Even just growing up in Venice [California], it was very funky, a lot of very adventurous and unique people.”
Was that something that supported you in choosing your career?
“Definitely. There are many privileges that come with growing up around artists, and I think one of them was just the fact that I got this front-row seat to what that might look like from a very young age, and a lot of exposure to what this career and what this process was. It was both daunting and really exciting. It makes you hungry for it, and you get to see a lot of the wonder of it, and that draws you in.”
How has New York City influenced you as an actor?
“The type of actor that lives in New York was the type of actor that really excited me, and the type of art making that happens in New York also really excited me. My problem with LA is that it is an industry town, which I think makes it harder, for me at least, to be inspired by or surprised by everyday things that have nothing to do with the work that we do. And the beauty of New York is that there are so many spontaneously occurring sources of inspiration here, whether it's because the people here are extraordinary and so real and so themselves, or the type of art that is shown here, not just theater, but visual art, music, culinary arts that are ever-changing here.’
In LA, the lifestyle prioritizes being comfortable, and in New York, as soon as you walk out the door, you're challenged, and I think that that's conducive to growth, both creatively and personally.”
Prada dress, shoes, and bag.Tell me what your routine is like when you're filming?
“I tend to be a bit of a grandparent when I'm working. I try to get a lot of sleep. I use weekends for work, but I always try to make sure that I get at least one non-work-related adventure of some kind in. Most of the time, I'm trying to be pretty gentle with myself and maintain my physical and emotional health, because I need that to get through the week. But I think my day-to-day changes depending on the job. With Stick, it's so wonderful and peaceful and joyful on set, and we're outside all day. So going home is just a lot of rest, and a lot of sunscreen is really my focus.”
On the topic of doing non-work-related things, I'm curious about hobbies at the moment. Do you have any or want to have any?
“There are a lot of things that I want to do. There are a lot of things that I've tried to cultivate and been less than consistent with. Something that I'm interested in right now—and maybe it's because I'm moving house—I really would like to get into carpentry because I'd like to start building things for my own home. I think it’s so empowering and exciting, to be able to generate something from your imagination and have it tangibly in front of you. It's the exact opposite of what I do for work. There's this ephemeral, intangible blob of a thing that we're creating, so it's very wonderful to get to imagine something and make it and use it."
Prada dress, shoes, and bag.What do you do for fun in NYC?
“I'm a fiend for art, so usually I’ll peek at some galleries on a free day. Sometimes with friends, sometimes solo. There’s always something exciting to see in the city. In decent weather, I'll try to find some green space and explore a little. Also food. Always food.”
What's the most inspiring moment you've had while living here?
“There have been so many. I think the tiny ones more than anything. Folks helping each other carry furniture down the block, huddling under an awning in summer rain, soaked and laughing. New York has a lot of moments like those.”
Where do you go to find inspiration?
“I immediately want to say art spaces, books, movies…that kind of thing. But actually, I probably look more to people. The people in my life, how they move through the world… that inspires me more than anything.”
Louis Vuitton jacket.Tell me about what you love about where you are in your life right now?
“Oh my God, there's a lot. I have the most amazing community of people around me right now, which is such a joy. As I've gotten older, I've tried to be so intentional about who I have around me, and I feel so extraordinarily lucky to have the friends that I have in my life, and the family that I have in my life. Many of us are now gathered in the same place, and that is so special and so amazing to return to after time away. It's so cool to have people who motivate you and inspire and challenge you. And I really feel that I have that right now.”
What is the most challenging thing about your job right now?
“I feel so lucky to get to do it, that any challenge that comes with it still feels rewarding and positive. Something that’s hard is being away from the people you love, whether it's family or friends or a partner. We all struggle with it and deal with it in different ways, and it definitely is the most challenging logistical part of this work.”
Speaking of rewarding, what is the most rewarding part?
“This work is such a joy and so magical. If we didn't feel that way, we wouldn't do it. But for me, whenever I'm met with something that I look at and go, ‘Oh my God, I don't really know if I can do this’ or ‘I don't know how I'm going to do this,’ and then I do it, that's the most rewarding and exciting and mind-blowing part of the job. Because you grow so much and so rapidly as a person and as an artist through this work. That's the most rewarding part: watching yourself expand in ways you didn't know that you could.”
Louis Vuitton dress, hat, and shoes.Photography: Jenna Saraco
Styling: Ella O'Keeffe
Fashion Assistant: McKenzie Stoute
Hair: Nai'vasha
Makeup: Anastasia Vavina
